Ayasa: Shadows of Silence Review

“Light through the darkness, darkness through the light”
Introduction
Ayasa: Shadows of Silence had my curiosity piqued from the first trailer. With heavy Little Nightmares and INSIDE vibes, Ayasa: Shadows of Silence by developer Aya Games seemed to have some potential. I’m all for games that have surreal horror infused with themes of darkness and life. Well folks, after having played this quite short indie darling, I have some thoughts on it. Will Ayasa: Shadows of Silence rise to the levels of the games it takes homage from, or does this game fall into the abyss of mediocrity? Time to find out in our review of Ayasa: Shadows of Silence for the PS5! Big thanks to Aya Games for the review code!
Gameplay

Ayasa: Shadows of Silence does indeed feel right at home compared to titles like Little Nightmares, LIMBO, and so on. Players assume the role of a young soul who seems lost in a world that is both nightmarish and similar to our own. Cities exist but seem bigger than they should, giant creatures lurk in the darkness, and odd entities try to seemingly survive in this almost post-apocalyptic land. In order for you to survive yourself, you’re going to need your wit and the ability to platform…which isn’t always done in the best way.
Ayasa: Shadows of Silence feels often quite fluid movement wise and does mimic the movement I get playing Little Nightmares or INSIDE. The problem when you compare the two though is Ayasa: Shadows of Silence can feel off at times. I died a lot and not due to a skill issue (sometimes though it was a skill issue) because jumping from one ledge to another didn’t feel natural or was slightly off when I made the jump. The same can be said of stealth sequences where I was caught at times just because…literally not because I failed to use a power or moved near an enemy but because they just turned to me and ran. Stuff like that is annoying and happens a tad too much.
Platforming aside, there are moments where your girl gains powers like rewinding the environment’s damage or turning invisible. These can be utilized in rather cool ways, but I feel like these powers I’ve seen in other games before. I think that’s one of my gripes of Ayasa: Shadows of Silence…nothing feels overly original. Yes, it works…usually, but I wasn’t ever invested in Ayasa: Shadows of Silence because of the gameplay. Luckily, the other aspects of this title are what makes it way better. Oh, and I’d be remiss to not mention there are two endings in Ayasa: Shadows of Silence based on choices made in the game, so those who love replaying games will have a reason to re-enter this game’s dark world.
Graphics

Ayasa: Shadows of Silence is said to take themes from art creators like Tim Burton, Rene Laloux, Hayao Miyazaki, and Sergey Paradjanov, and I can see that in various facets. The character models and numerous biomes you enter all have this surreal feeling which those creators are known for doing. Art wise, Ayasa: Shadows of Silence is fantastic, but visually and like its gameplay, there are moments of inconsistencies. The most notable is some of the various landscapes can look great and also a bit flat. Larger areas like city scapes and giant rooms can often be quite detailed at one moment and then look mediocre the next. Do I think Ayasa: Shadows of Silence looks bad visually? Not at all, I just also feel it screams indie in the worst ways at times, an unfortunate byproduct of a game with lesser resources than a bigger company sadly.
Sound
There are two areas Ayasa: Shadows of Silence succeeds in, one is without a doubt in the sound department. The OST in Ayasa: Shadows of Silence is incredible to say the least. While there’s no voiced dialogue, the music is what captures the player in the simplest moments and the action intense sequences. Komitas is credited for the game’s soundtrack and after doing some digging, I can see their music is quite great even outside Ayasa: Shadows of Silence.
Story

Stories don’t always need to be straightforward to be great. I think that’s what Ayasa: Shadows of Silence does so well. Despite being entirely silent, Ayasa: Shadows of Silence has a deep narrative that is rewarding to those who try to understand it. The narrative itself isn’t the easiest to get in one playthrough and I found online videos and stories helped piece together what I couldn’t understand, but I think even those stories could be seen as one possible way to understand Ayasa: Shadows of Silence. Is this a tale of judgment? Are you playing someone looking for redemption or proving that they can overcome any challenge regardless of choice? With two endings, Ayasa: Shadows of Silence has a story that warrants replaying it and I would say the story is where this game succeeds almost perfectly.
Overall Impression

Ayasa: Shadows of Silence comes close to being a fantastic game, very close. There are some issues in various areas, but where the game works is by presenting a great silent story with a fantastic soundtrack and some okay platforming. Ayasa: Shadows of Silence might not measure the same against games like it, but for an indie title done with a smaller budget and I presume team, it is a good game.
Pros
- Story with quite some depth that can be examined in a multitude of ways
- Fantastic soundtrack that really captures every moment well
- Multiple endings give reason to replay the title
Cons
- Platforming can feel very imprecise at times
- Gameplay isn’t anything I haven’t seen before and can be quite generic at times
- Visuals are at times good and bad in equal measure for an inconsistent feel
Overall Score
7.5
Conclusion

I hope it doesn’t seem like I’m being hard on Ayasa: Shadows of Silence, but I feel it comes so close to being amazing and just has little issues that keep it from being fantastic. For what it’s worth, I think the game deserves a play as it’s not overly expensive for a game that probably can take you 2-3 hours if you go for both endings. Still, the problems Ayasa: Shadows of Silence has are still relevant and that’s why I can understand some maybe wanting to wait for a sale if $19.99 seems too steep for such a short game. Regardless of your decision, I recommend Ayasa: Shadows of Silence and think it deserves some of your time for at the very least story and OST!